-
By mid-September, Small Oak had learned so much. How to be sanctuary. How to compost shame. How to trust his three kinds of knowing. How to understand that behaviour is communication.
But there was one more lesson waiting.
It began on a morning when Small Oak woke to find Tiny Sapling—still barely bigger than an acorn, still growing in his shelter—trembling.
“What’s wrong?” Small Oak asked, leaning to create more shelter for her.
“Deer,” Tiny Sapling whispered. “They came in the night. They ate my leaves. Almost all of them.”
Small Oak could see it was true. Tiny Sapling’s few precious leaves—the ones she needed to catch sunlight, to grow, to survive—had been browsed down to stubs.
“I’m so sorry,” Small Oak said, and he meant it. He leaned closer, creating more shade, being as gentle as he could. “You’re safe now. I’m here. You’ll grow new leaves.”
But even as he said it, he could smell the deer nearby. They hadn’t gone far. They’d be back tonight. And Tiny Sapling, already so small, might not survive another browsing.
“Being sorry isn’t enough,” said a sharp voice.
Small Oak looked. It was Blackthorn—a tree he’d noticed before but never really spoken to. She wasn’t tall, but she was strong. And she was covered in thorns. Long, sharp thorns that gleamed in the September light.
“What do you mean?” Small Oak asked.
“I mean,” said Blackthorn, and her voice was kind but firm, “that sometimes compassion needs teeth. Sometimes love needs to roar.”
Small Oak didn’t understand. “But I’m being gentle. I’m creating shelter. Isn’t that what we’re supposed to do?”
“That’s tender compassion,” said Grandmother Oak, and Small Oak heard something new in her voice—something proud and fierce. “And it’s beautiful. But there’s another kind of compassion too. Come—let me show you.”
Small Oak’s attention traveled to where Blackthorn stood. Up close, he could see that behind her thorns—nestled safe among all those sharp points—small blue sloes were forming. Precious fruit. Protected.
“The thorns aren’t cruelty,” Blackthorn explained. “They’re fierce love. I love my sloes. I won’t let anything steal them before they’re ripe. So I grow thorns. That’s not meanness. That’s mama bear energy. That’s saying: You will not harm what I’m protecting.“
Nearby, Hawthorn spoke up. She too was covered in spikes, and behind them, clusters of red berries were forming.
“When the deer come,” Hawthorn said, “they don’t browse us. They can’t. Our thorns say: No. Not this. This is protected. That’s fierce compassion.”
Small Oak felt confused. “But Grandmother Oak doesn’t have thorns. Does that mean she doesn’t love fiercely?”
“Watch,” said Grandmother Oak.
Just then, the Foresters appeared, carrying saws. They stopped near a young ash tree—healthy, growing well, doing nothing wrong except being in a spot they wanted for a path.
“This one needs to come down,” one Forester said.
And Grandmother Oak—gentle, patient Grandmother Oak—did something Small Oak had never seen before.
She sent a message through the listening net. Fast. Urgent. Strong.
No. This is not acceptable. This tree is healthy. This is our forest. We have a right to grow here. NO.
The message was so powerful that Small Oak felt it in his roots like thunder. It wasn’t a request. It wasn’t gentle persuasion. It was a roar—a line drawn in the soil that said: This far and no further.
Through the listening net, Small Oak felt other trees responding. Roots shifting. Messages amplifying. The whole forest speaking with one voice: No. We do not consent to this.
The Foresters hesitated. One looked uncomfortable. “Maybe we should reroute the path,” he said quietly.
They left. The young ash tree stayed standing.
“That,” said Grandmother Oak, and her voice was still gentle but underneath it was steel, “is fierce compassion. It’s not about having thorns on the outside. It’s about being willing to say no. Being willing to stand firm. Being willing to protect what’s precious—even when it’s uncomfortable, even when it makes others unhappy.”
Small Oak’s heartwood was racing (if trees’ hearts can race). “I didn’t know you could do that.”
“Most young trees don’t,” said Grandmother Oak. “They think compassion only looks soft. But real compassion—forest-deep compassion—knows when to be moss and when to be thorns.”
Around them, Small Oak began to notice what he’d never seen before. Brambles growing at the forest edge, their hooked spikes keeping larger animals from trampling the delicate wildflowers growing underneath. Holly trees with pointed leaves at the bottom—where deer might browse—and smooth leaves at the top where nothing could reach.
“This is fierce compassion,” said Blackthorn. “It’s action, not just sympathy. It’s changing things, not just comforting those who suffer. It’s mama bear saying: I will protect what matters, and I’m not asking permission.“
“But when do you know?” Small Oak asked. “When do you need to be gentle and when do you need to be fierce?”
“Both,” said Grandmother Oak. “Not balance—both. Sometimes at the same time.”
She gestured with her branches toward Tiny Sapling, still trembling at Small Oak’s base.
“Right now, Tiny Sapling needs your tender compassion—your shelter, your presence, your ‘you’re safe here.’ But she also needs your fierce compassion. She needs you to say to the deer: No. Not this one. This sapling is protected.“
“But I don’t have thorns,” Small Oak said quietly.
“You don’t need them,” said Grandmother Oak. “Fierce compassion isn’t about thorns or no thorns. It’s about being willing to act. To protect. To say no when no needs to be said. To stand firm when firm is what’s needed.”
She showed him then—showed him what oak trees do. How their bark contains tannins that make them taste bitter to deer. How they can send messages through the listening net: Danger here. Browse elsewhere. How even a young oak can create a boundary around what they’re protecting.
“You can grow a bitter taste in your bark where the deer might browse near Tiny Sapling,” Grandmother Oak explained. “You can send warnings through the listening net—not with hatred, but with clarity. You can be gentle with Tiny Sapling while being fierce about her boundaries. That’s what fierce compassion looks like.”
Small Oak felt the thick moss growing on Grandmother Oak’s north side—damp, soft, nurturing. And he thought about the steel in her voice when she’d sent that message to protect the young ash tree.
Both. She was both.
“What about...” Small Oak hesitated. “What about when I need fierce compassion for myself? When the Foresters wanted to stake me, and it felt wrong?”
“That’s when fierce self-compassion matters most,” said Grandmother Oak. “Sometimes you need to be gentle with yourself—rest when you’re tired, let go of shame, accept your pace. That’s tender self-compassion. But sometimes you need to be fierce with yourself—not cruel, but strong. Saying: I will not accept treatment that harms me. I will trust my own knowing even when others say I’m wrong. I will protect my own right to grow.“
Blackthorn’s thorns caught the afternoon light. “Fierce compassion is saying yes to your own well-being, even when others want you to say yes to their convenience. It’s speaking truth even when truth is uncomfortable. It’s refusing to accept what’s unacceptable.”
Small Oak thought about all of it. The thorns protecting sloes. The bitter bark protecting saplings. The message through the listening net protecting the young ash tree. The moss holding water. The dappled shade keeping seedlings safe.
“So I need to be both soft and strong?” he asked.
“Always,” said Grandmother Oak. “The forest needs you to shelter Tiny Sapling with tender compassion—to be present, accepting, nurturing. And the forest needs you to protect her with fierce compassion—to set boundaries, to say no to harm, to act, not just sympathize.”
That night, when the deer came back, Small Oak was ready.
He’d activated the bitter tannins in his bark near Tiny Sapling. He’d sent a clear message through the listening net—not angry, but firm: Not here. This one is protected. Browse elsewhere.
And he’d leaned to create shelter—tender compassion and fierce compassion, working together.
The deer moved on. Tiny Sapling stayed safe. And Small Oak learned what Grandmother Oak had known all along:
Real compassion isn’t just one thing. It’s moss and thorns. Shelter and boundaries. Acceptance and action. Gentleness and the willingness to roar.
“The forest doesn’t choose between them,” Grandmother Oak said as the stars came out. “The forest needs both. And so do you. Be tender when tenderness is needed. Be fierce when fierceness is needed. And sometimes—often—be both at once.”
Small Oak felt the moss on Grandmother Oak’s trunk. Felt the steel in her roots. Felt his own capacity for both—to shelter and to protect, to comfort and to defend, to be soft and to be strong.
He was learning to be forest.
And the forest, he was beginning to understand, was learning to be both gentle and fierce through him.